Directly confirming or refuting concrete scientific research (i.e., proving that the heat from the tandir doubles blood circulation and that this protects against cancer) for the statements cited by Governor Zoyir Mirzayev regarding the link between women not baking tandir bread and oncological diseases is unavailable.
However, the following aspects are widely discussed in the scientific community:
1. About Hyperthermia (Treatment with Heat)
Aspect partially consistent with the Governor's claim: In modern medicine, hyperthermia (or thermal therapy) is used as an auxiliary method of oncological treatment. Here, doctors use controlled heating of tumor tissues (usually up to 41°C to 44°C) to damage cancer cells or make them more sensitive to chemotherapy and radiation therapy.
Aspect inconsistent with the Tandir: This treatment method is directed to a precise location using high-tech medical equipment and fundamentally differs from naturally heating the entire body, especially by standing in front of a tandir. The heat from the tandir might accelerate blood circulation to some extent, but its ability to provide the same precise and permanent oncological protection as medical hyperthermia is not proven.
2. Traditional Bread and Health
Difference in the bread itself: The Governor emphasized the benefits of bread made with black wheat. Generally, whole grain or black wheat products contain more fiber, vitamins, and minerals than bread made from ordinary white flour (e.g., achchiq bulka), which is beneficial for the health of the gastrointestinal tract.
Harmful factors: Conversely, some studies have shown that the level of carcinogenic compounds like Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) can be higher in bread baked in traditional tandirs (especially when coal or wood is used as fuel) compared to bread baked in gas or electric ovens. From the perspective of the tandir smoke's effect on breathing and product quality, this could pose an additional health risk.
3. Low Mobility and Cancer (The Governor's first factor)
Scientific Basis: The Governor's assertion that "low mobility is in the first place" is fully confirmed by modern medicine. Lack of physical activity is one of the main factors increasing the risk of many chronic diseases, including breast, colon, and endometrial cancer. Baking bread in a tandir (kneading the dough, rolling it out, and sticking it to the tandir) is an active endeavor, and in this regard, the loss of the tradition can indeed increase low mobility.
Conclusion
Baking bread in a tandir is a cultural and physical activity, and the consumption of black wheat bread falls under proper nutrition. However, the Governor's opinion that "warming up in front of the tandir cleans the blood and protects against cancer" is not directly or formally confirmed by current scientific sources and cannot be accepted as medical advice.
Read “Zamin” on Telegram!
Users of Меҳмон are not allowed to comment this publication.
