Eldor or Dovbyk? Who should be Roma’s main striker?

Although AS Roma had an unsuccessful start to the season, the team is now entering the battle as a serious contender for top positions that grant qualification to European competitions.

The experienced coach Claudio Ranieri, who took over the team in the second half of November, is proving in practice that it is possible to achieve high results without significantly changing the lineup. During this period, Eldor Shomurodov, who was close to leaving the club twice, has also reached a new stage in his career.

In recent matches, the Uzbek legionnaire has become one of the most influential players in Roma's squad. As a result, Roman fans and experts have begun comparing Eldor Shomurodov with Artem Dovbyk.

It is worth reminding that Dovbyk was signed last summer for 30 million euros and was seen as the main striker from the start of the season. However, today many experts emphasize that Shomurodov should be seen as a first-choice player.

Observers note that although Dovbyk has scored more goals, in terms of commitment, dedication, and activity, Eldor is far ahead of his rival. Therefore, he deserves more time on the field.

Renowned football analyst Riccardo Trevisani shared the following opinion in an interview with “Roma News”:

– Watching Dovbyk’s play is often not enjoyable. If he doesn't score, he's almost useless to the team. Yet a striker must contribute even without goals. There are forwards who play very well without scoring. Dovbyk is not one of them. In the Rome derby, Eldor Shomurodov played better than him.

Dovbyk is 190 cm tall and weighs 90 kg, but he still can’t win duels, which frustrates me. No opponents are afraid of him anymore. He cannot use his physique, and that’s not normal. Meanwhile, Eldor is leading the team forward with pressure, effort, and commitment.

The analysis from “Corriere dello Sport” aligns with Trevisani's opinion:

– Dovbyk still fails to make a decisive impact in crucial matches. The derbies against Lazio are not just games — they require a real leader. Unfortunately, he fails to step up in such moments.

With such body and physical attributes, Dovbyk must fight harder for the ball, be more active in pressing, and show his strength. There’s a growing belief that if Artem doesn't score, he doesn't help the team.

Many fans and experts note that if Eldor Shomurodov played as a central striker, his constant pressing would drive the team forward.

In response to this criticism, Dovbyk’s supporters argue that he needs more time to adapt to Serie A. They highlight the vast difference between the style of football in Spain and Italy.

At the same time, the number of Shomurodov’s fans is increasing daily. They emphasize that the Uzbek player’s activity on the pitch, his dueling ability, and contribution to the team are the main reasons why he should be seen as the main striker.

Dear fans, who do you think is more beneficial for Roma: Artem Dovbyk or Eldor Shomurodov? Expensive transfer or loyalty and hard work? We await your opinions in the comments! Read 'Zamin' on Telegram!